europa-list
[Top] [All Lists]

Re: Europa-List: Re: Europa accident G-HOFC - PFA comment

Subject: Re: Europa-List: Re: Europa accident G-HOFC - PFA comment
From: Rowland & Wilma Carson <rowil@clara.net>
Date: Mon, 30 Jul 2007 19:05:57


>Not only did this plane have a full factory tank of fuel, Ken,much 
>to my dismay, also had 1 or 2 aux plastic Evinrude tanks that 
>erupted upon impact

Finklea - I am very sad to hear that an experienced pilot was 
persuaded to be aboard an aircraft with such a dangerous-sounding 
fuel arrangment.

The likelihood of surviving a low-level stall-spin incident is low at 
the best of times; I would not care to stack the odds against myself 
by adding a potential bomb to my baggage.

Was the Evinrude tank restrained & plumbed-in in a way that minimised 
any possibility of fuel spillage on impact? I've not looked at the 
factory-supplied long range tank, but I'm sure it addresses these 
concerns. If you choose a different route to provide more fuel on 
board, you're conducting an experiment, the result of which, by 
definition, is unknown.

What was the gross weight & CG of the aircraft at departure? Two 
adults (how heavy?) plus the extra fuel tank(s) might have put it 
over-gross or out of balance; maybe there was some baggage aboard 
too. Did the Pilot-in-Command conduct a weight and balance 
calculation before departure? Did the PiC review the options for 
dealing with engine-failure-after-takeoff before depature?

I've just be re-validating my licence in C152s (a factory-built type 
with a fairly good safety record); much of the dual time was spent, 
not seeing if I could keep the dirty side down or find some distant 
waypoint, but on exploring my ability (a) to make sure the aircraft 
and its systems were fit for flight before committing to takeoff, and 
(b) to make decisions that would contribute to my survival in the 
event of unexpected failures. It was not assumed that this simple and 
basically safe type would refuse to bite if the pilot took his eye 
off the ball, and the same is true of all aircraft types.

regards

Rowland
-- 
| Rowland Carson  PFA #16532    http://home.clara.net/rowil/aviation/
| 760 hours building Europa #435 G-ROWI  e-mail <rowil@clara.net>



<Prev in Thread] Current Thread [Next in Thread>